
Catherine Webb - The Extraordinary and Unusual Adventures of Horatio Lyle
The Extraordinary and Unusual Adventures of Horatio Lyle
Catherine Webb
2006, 311 pages
Upon reading a rave review from a friend, who also forced the book upon me a year or so later, I knew I would have to read Horatio Lyle, if only to know what she’s been raving about for so long. I’m not typically a young adult book fan, and I don’t think this book is going to turn me into a convert, but it was definitely good.
It’s your typical Young Adult fare; plucky 18th century detective has to team up with plucky young thief and plucky young rich boy to solve a mystery using fun, adventure, and a little bit of random science. It seems inevitable that the boy and the girl will hook up in the 3rd or 4th book, and that the detective will blunder through if not for the help of the children. In the end, the mystery is solved, people get scraped up a bit but nobody dies, and we all learn a little bit about the people who live on the other side of the tracks. It’s all very wholesome, straightforward and expected.
So what I didn’t expect was that I would actually like it. I didn’t really love any of the characters, and I wasn’t left gushing about how awesome Horatio was, or how much I loved his mom, or anything like that, but it was really well written.
Nothing bugs me more than when books set in the past that don’t get their facts straight. I haven’t done any research to verify this, but I think Catherine Webb actually got the science and history right in this book as well. I certainly appreciated Webb’s attention to detail in that respect. She writes action very well; even her sentence structure at times implies how slowly or quickly events are unfolding. That’s very difficult to do, and she did it very well. Catherine Webb was only nineteen when she wrote this book, and on that itself, I know I will pick up the other books, if only to see her development as an author.
So I didn’t love it, mostly because I don’t love YA fiction, but it was very good. If I was trying to get a young teen into reading, this is a book I would buy for them.